In current WHHLMI rabbits, aortic atherosclerosis is observed from 2 months of age, despite being fed a normal standard rabbit diet.
Lesions first occur at the openings of the arterial branches.
At 6 months of age, aortic lesions extend to approximately 40% of the aortic surface (arch, thoracic, and upper abdominal areas).
At 12 months of age, lesions extend to the abdominal aorta, covering approximately 70% of the aortic surface.
Beyond 18 months of age, aortic lesions cover most of the aorta.
Regarding the lesional composition (
Arterioscler Thromb 1994; 14: 931-937; J Atheroscler Thromb 1994; 1: 45-52), early lesions have many macrophages in the intima and few smooth muscle cells, with some macrophages infiltrating the arterial media. In transitional lesions observed at around 12 months of age, there is an increase in large foamy cells derived from macrophages deep in the intima, and the surface is covered with a fibromuscular cap. After 18 months of age, the cellular components decrease, but collagen fibers, extracellular lipid accumulation, and cholesterol creft increase. In some cases, calcium accumulation is observed in these advanced lesions.
Occurence of coronary lesions
The mutant rabbits from which the WHHL rabbits were derived had severe atherosclerotic lesions in the coronary arteries. However, during the development of the WHHL rabbit line, the mutant rabbits were crossed with normal rabbits (JW rabbits), and when the line was established, the incidence of coronary lesions was very low. As a result of selective breeding (
see "Development of the WHHL rabbit line"), coronary lesions were observed from 2 months of age, even when fed a standard diet. Lesions occur mainly in the left main coronary trunk, the origin of the right coronary artery, and the left circumflex artery.
In rabbits, the left circumflex artery is thicker and longer than the left anterior descending artery (
J Ateroscler Thromb 2018; 25:393-404).
In WHHLMI rabbits, the average percent coronary stenosis of the circumflex artery (percentage of plaque area in the area surrounding the internal elastic lamina) is approximately 50% at 6 months of age, approximately 70% at 12 months of age, and approximately 80% at 18 months of age or older (
Exp Anim 2004;53:339-346).
Components of coronary lesions
The lesion composition of coronary plaques in WHHLMI rabbits is relatively fibromuscular compared to aortic lesions (
Arterioscler Thromb 1994; 14: 931-937, Exp Anim 2004;53:339-346).
However, several WHHLMI rabbits show macrophage-rich coronary plaques.
Many WHHLMI rabbits have vulnerable plaques (lesions consisting of large lipid core covered by a thin fibrous cap) in the coronary arteries that lead to acute myocardial infarction.
Coronary response to serotonin
Coronary arteries with atherosclerotic lesions exhibited the enhanced contraction and Ca
2+ mobilization in response to serotonin.
The 5-HT
1B receptor, which is upregulated by atherosclerosis, are thought to mediate the enhancing effects of serotonin (
Circulation 2001; 103: 1289-1295).
Outward remodeling of coronary arteries
Coronary arteries with atherosclerotic lesions show outward remodeling, and WHHLMI rabbits, which are prone to coronary atherosclerosis, are useful animals for studying coronary outward remodeling. We have demonstrated new insights into the preservation of the coronary lumen during the progression of coronary atherosclerosis (
Coronary Artery Disease 2004 Nov; 15(7): 419-426);
・ | Previous quantitative analysis of coronary compensatory remodeling was limited by individual differences in arterial diameter and tapering. We developed a new analytical method to overcome this limitation and analyzed coronary outward remodeling using perfusion-fixed coronary arteries of WHHL rabbits, which are prone to coronary atherosclerosis. In this new analysis, we evaluated how the lumen area or arterial diameter changes with the accumulation of atherosclerotic plaque compared to before plaque formation. Lumen area decreased slowly below 10% of cross-sectional narrowing (CSN), remained constant from 10% to 68% CSN, and decreased rapidly above 70% CSN despite continued outward remodeling. Up to 70% CSN, arterial remodeling progressed quantitatively, maintaining constant arterial wall shear stress and lumen area. Quantitative analysis, which eliminated previous limitations, provided the novel insight that outward remodeling of coronary arteries in atherosclerosis maintains lumen size in proportion to wall shear stress up to 70% CSN. |
・ | There is a phenomenon in which it is speculated that in areas where macrophages accumulate in the deep layer of intimal lesions, the arterial media is attenuated, and fibroblast-like cells in the arterial adventitia change into smooth muscle cells (Atherosclerosis 2008;198:287-293). This observation suggests that the thinned arterial media may be reinforced from the adventitia side of the artery. The repeated erosion of the arterial media by macrophages and reinforcement of the media from the adventitia side may cause the coronary artery to expand outward. (Atherosclerosis 2008;198:287-293). From this observation, it seems that the thin artery media may reinforce from the adventitial side of the artery. |
Correlation between coronary artery running pattern and severity of coronary lesions
Even if serum cholesterol levels are the same, there are large individual differences in the progression of coronary artery disease. It has been suggested that these individual differences may be related to the courserunning pattern of the coronary arteries. The more curvature there is in the coronary artery, the more advanced the coronary artery stenosis is(
J Atheroscler Thromb 2018;25:393-404).
Serum markers for coronary lesions
Metabolomic analysis using WHHLMI rabbits identified serum markers specific to coronary artery lesions (
Atherosclerosis 2019;284:18-23).
・ | At 4 months of age, the age at which coronary artery lesions develop, WHHLMI rabbits with severe coronary artery lesions had high serum lysophosphatidylcholine (LPC) 22:4 concentrations and low serum diacylglycerol 18:0-18:0 concentrations. |
・ | At 8 months of age, when coronary lesions progress rapidly, citrate + isocitrate, pyroglutamic acid, LPC 20:4 (sn-2), and Cer d18:1-18:2 were higher in WHHLMI rabbits with severe coronary lesions. |
・ | At 16 months of age, when most coronary arteries were occluded and myocardial ischemia had developed, serum phosphatidylethanolamine plasma levels 16:1p-22:2 were higher in WHHLMI rabbits. |
3). Cerebral artery lesions
Cerebral atherosclerosis was not observed in WHHL rabbits prior to 1995, but in WHHL rabbits prone to coronary atherosclerosis (
see "Development of the WHHL rabbit line"), cerebral atherosclerosis develops spontaneously in 9 months or more without inducing hypertension
(
Atherosclerosis 2001; 156 (1): 57-66 ).
These lesions are observed mainly in the vertebral artery, basilar artery, confluence of vertebral arteries, and branches of basilar arteries
(
Atherosclerosis 2001; 156 (1): 57-66 ; Exp Anim. 2019 Jul;68(3):293-300 ).
However, no lesions were observed in the penetrating arteries.
The severity of the lesion is relatively mild and the lesion is fibromuscular.
The development of cerebral atherosclerosis is not associated with blood pressure in our WHHL rabbits.
4). Other arterial lesions
Atherosclerotic lesions are also observed in pulmonary, carotid, renal, mesenteric, celiac, and other arteries in WHHLMI rabbits, but not in small arteries (
Exp Anim 2001;50:423-426; Exp Anim 2019;68:293-300).
Carotid artery lesions are observed at the bifurcation from around 6 months of age, and the composition of the lesions is diverse (atherosclerotic plaques, fibrous lesions, etc.), similar to coronary artery lesions.
Macrophage-rich lesions develope in the pulmonary artery, and fibrotic lesions are observed in the renal artery and the iliac-femoral artery. In the celiac arteries and superior mesenteric arteries, atheromatous lesions are observed.
Furthermore, when WHHLMI rabbits were over 20 months of age, macrophage-derived foam cells were observed in the aortic valve, and as the lesion progressed, the aortic valve thickened and calcium accumulation was observed, leading to the development of aortic stenosis (
Atherosclerosis 2018;273:8-14).
IV. The characteristics of WHHLMI rabbit (Arterioscler Thromb Vasc Biol 2003;23 (7): 1239-1244); Commentary to the International Atherosclerosis Society, IAS Website (http://www.athero.org/comm-index.asp) September 5, 2003.; Exp Anim 2004; 53 (4): 339-346; J Atheroscler Thromb 2004 Sep; 11 (4): 184-189)
・ | The WHHLMI rabbit is the first rabbit model that spontaneously develops myocardial infarction even under restricted feeding of a standard diet (Arterioscler Thromb Vasc Biol 2003;23 (7): 1239-1244). |
・ | WHHLMI rabbits die suddenly without obvious symptoms after 10 months of age, and histological analysis reveals myocardial infarction in 97% of rabbits that die by 35 months of age (Exp Anim 2004; 53 (4): 339-346). |
・ | The myocardial lesions were widely distributed in the left ventricle, right ventricle, and interventricular septum, and the coronary arteries showed severe coronary stenosis (Exp Anim 2004; 53 (4): 339-346). |
・ | The anatomical location of myocardial infarction is classified as subendocardial, intramural, transmural, or subepicardial infarction (Arterioscler Thromb Vasc Biol 2003;23 (7): 1239-1244)). |
・ | In many WHHLMI rabbits, old myocardial lesions are accompanied by fresh myocardial lesions (Arterioscler Thromb Vasc Biol 2003;23 (7): 1239-1244). |
・ | In WHHLMI rabbits above 20 months of age, 73% of LCX segments show cross-sectional narrowing greater than 90%. |
・ | Electrocardiograms observed in WHHLMI rabbits immediately prior to sudden death showed typical electrocardiogram changes observed during acute myocardial infarction in humans (Arterioscler Thromb Vasc Biol 2003;23 (7): 1239-1244). |
・ | These results suggest that in WHHLMI rabbits, myocardial ischemia occurs repeatedly as coronary artery lesions progress, and the final myocardial ischemic event leads to sudden death. |
・ | Compared with WHHL rabbits before selective breeding, both aortic and coronary artery lesions were significantly more advanced (Exp Anim 2004; 53 (4): 339-346). |
・ | The serum total cholesterol levels of WHHLMI rabbits were increased by approximately 200 mg/dl compared with those of WHHL rabbits before selective breeding, but triglyceride levels were similar. |
・ | In WHHLMI rabbits, serum total cholesterol levels were higher in females than in males, but there were no significant gender differences in aortic lesions, coronary artery lesions, or myocardial infarction (Exp Anim 2004; 53 (4): 339-346). |
・ | Although serum total cholesterol levels in WHHLMI rabbits did not correlate with the occurrence of myocardial infarction, the cross-sectional narrowing of ??the coronary artery did correlate with the occurrence of myocardial infarction (Exp Anim 2004; 53 (4): 339-346). |
・ | The culprit coronary arteries of WHHLMI rabbits that died of myocardial infarction have occlusive lesions with large lipid cores covered by thin fibrous caps, calcium deposits, and intralesion hemorrhage (Arterioscler Thromb Vasc Biol 2003;23 (7): 1239-1244)). |
・ | Despite the presence of such vulnerable plaques in WHHLMI rabbits, plaque rupture and intramural thrombus, as observed in human acute coronary syndromes, are not observed, suggesting that the involvement of secondary factors is required for ruptur of vulnerable plaques (Exp Anim 2017; 66 (2): 145-157). |
・ | A variety of lesions were seen in the coronary arteries of WHHLMI rabbits, including atherosclerotic lesions, unstable lesions consisting of a large lipid core covered by a thin fibrous cap, fibrotic lesions, lesions with multiple layers of fibrous components combined with macrophages and lipid components, fatty plaques, calcium deposits, and vasa vasorum (Exp Anim 2017; 66 (2): 145-157). |
・ | In WHHLMI rabbits, drug-induced coronary artery spasm (confirmed by coronary angiography) led to myocardial ischemia (confirmed by electrocardiogram), myocardial damage (confirmed by serum levels of heart-type fatty acid?binding protein, cardiac troponin-I, and myoglobin), and ventricular dysfunction (confirmed by echocardiography), resulting in myocardial infarction. Induction of coronary artery spasm resulted in intimal damage (60.9%), endothelial cell protrusion (39.1%), intimal detachment (30.4%), macrophage extravasation (56.5%), and plaque destruction and intraluminal thrombosis in 2 of 23 animals (8.7%) (Arterioscler Thromb Vasc Biol 2013; 33 (11): 2518-23). |
・ | WHHLMI rabbits are expected to contribute to research into myocardial regeneration through gene therapy. |
・ | The WHHLMI rabbits will be useful for studying the mechanisms of plaque stability and plaque rupture, as well as other risk factors inducing acute coronary syndromes. |
・ | In WHHLMI rabbits, although there was no difference in aortic lesion area or serum lipid levels, there was a large difference in the age at onset of myocardial infarction and the progression of coronary artery lesions, suggesting the existence of factors specific to coronary artery lesions (J Ateroscler Thromb 2018;25:393-404). |
・ | Serum markers of coronary atherosclerosis were detected by lipidome analyses of WHHLMI rabbits, which are specific for coronary artery lesions and are independent of cholesterol levels or aortic lesions (Atherosclerosis 2019; 284: 18-23). |
V. Other property
VI. Inheritance mode of hypercholesterolemia and coronay atherosclerosis
1. Hypercholesterolemia
Results of cross-breeding between homozygous WHHL rabbits and normal rabbits show that the offfspring had normal plasma cholesterol levels.
Rabbits with hypercholesterolemia are observed in about half of the offsprig in cross-breeding between homozygous WHHL rabbits withand heterozygous WHHL rabbits, and in about one-fourth of the offspring in cross-breeding between heterozygous WHHL rabbits with heterozygous WHHL rabbits.
In cross-breeding of homozygous WHHL rabbits with homozygous WHHL rabbits, all offspring suffer from hypercholesterolemia.
These results indicate that hypercholesterolemia is genetically recessive in WHHL rabbits (
Bull Azabu Vet Coll 1977; 2: 99-124 (Japanese)).
In our experience, when fed a standard diet, plasma total cholesterol levels at 3 months of age were less than 300 mg/dl in heterozygous WHHL rabbits and more than 300 mg/dl in homozygous rabbits.
In human familial hypercholesterolemia caused by an abnormality in the LDL receptor gene, the plasma total cholesterol level in heterozygous patients is intermediate between that of homozygous patients and healthy subjects, and hypercholesterolemia is inherited dominantly. Hypercholesterolemia in WHHL rabbits is also caused by an abnormality in the LDL receptor gene, but the plasma total cholesterol level in heterozygous rabbits is almost normal.
In experiments using fibroblasts, LDL receptor protein synthesis in WHHL rabbit heterozygotes was approximately 50% of that in normal cells (
Mol Biol Med 1983; 1(3): 353-367), and LDL binding activity was approximately 50% of that in normal cells (
Eur J Biochem 1981;557-564).
The reason for this difference in plasma total cholesterol levels between human familial hypercholesterolemia heterozygotes and WHHL rabbit heterozygotes is unclear, but it may be due to differences in the diets of rabbits and humans, since standard rabbit chow contains little lipid.
2. Coronary atherosclerosis
Despite having similar plasma cholesterol levels, not all WHHL rabbits developed coronary atherosclerosis. Even when males with severe coronary artery disease were mated with females with severe coronary artery disease, the extent of progression of coronary artery disease in the offspring varied.
The result of selective breeding suggests that the onset and/or progression of coronary atherosclerosis is regulated by multiple genes (
Atherosclerosis 1985; 56: 71-79; Atherosclerosis 1992; 96: 43-52). In addition, in the absence of appropriate selective breeding, the severity of coronary artery disease was reduced. These observations suggest that multiple genes are involved in the development and progression of coronary artery disease.
Although the entire genome of rabbits, including WHHL rabbits, has been published, genes involved in the development and progression of coronary artery lesions have not yet been identified (
Sci Rep. 2016 Jun 1;6:26942).
VII. Acute Coronary Syndromes
In human coronary arteries, there are atherosclerotic lesions consisting of a partially thinned fibrous cap covering a large lipid core (vulnerable plaque), and it is believed that rupture of these lesions can lead to sudden cardiac death.
Such unstable lesions were also observed in the coronary arteries of WHHLMI rabbits, but no ruptured coronary plaques were observed under normal conditions.
Therefore, we hypothesized that a secondary factor is required for rupture of unstable coronary plaques and examined whether unstable coronary plaque would rupture by inducing coronary vasospasm.(
Arterioscler Thromb Vasc Biol. 2013 Nov; 33(11): 2518-2523).
When WHHLMI rabbits were given a bolus of ergonovine intravenously while receiving a continuous infusion of norepinephrine, ST elevation and ST depression were observed on the electrocardiogram, and these changes were normalized by administration of nitroglycerin.
Coronary angiography showed a decrease in coronary blood flow with ergonovine administration and a restoration of coronary blood flow with nitroglycerin administration. These changes indicate the development of coronary artery spasm.
Echocardiography showed that systolic ventricular diameter was enlarged after the onset of coronary artery spasm, resulting in cardiac systolic dysfunction. Serum myocardial ischemia markers (H-FABP, c-troponin I, and myoglobin) were elevated 4 hours after the onset of coronary artery spasm.
In pathological examination of coronary plaques, eruptions of macrophages into the lumen from endothelial clefts were observed, and in a few cases, thrombus formation accompanied by rupture of coronary plaques was also observed.
VIII. Other abnormal findings
・ | Torticollis, which occurs in about 10% of WHHLMI rabbits, is not due to infection but is caused by differences in the growth of the mandible (J Exper Anim Technol 2007; 42 (1): 1-8 ). This difference in the growth of the left and right mandibles is thought to be due to an abnormality in the GRIP 1 gene (Sci Rep. 2016 Jun 1;6:26942), which is involved in facial asymmetry. |
・ | Keratopathy occurs in approximately 10% of WHHLMI rabbits. Some rabbits may develop cloudy white eyes (Vet Pathol 1988; 25(2): 173-174). The cause is thought to be macrophage infiltration into the cornea. |
・ | Although very rare, tumors such as lymphomas develop. |
・ | Genetic abnormalities: In addition to the LDL receptor gene, WHHLMI rabbits have been reported to have abnormalities in the following genes:(Sci Rep. 2016 Jun 1;6:26942)
ALDH2, VWF, DOCK4, NPY, OLR1, NOD1, BIRC8, SP110, RBFOX3, ZNF274, GRIP1, CRHR2, FGF10, QPRT, HCK, and CHRM2 |
IX. Species difference (Comparison with transgenic or KO mice)
Please see the table summarizing species differences:
Essence of species difference about lipoprotein metabolism, atherosclerosis, and myocardial characteristics(PDF)
The lipoprotein metabolism and arterial lesions in rabbits are similar to those in humans, but in mice they are significantly different from those in humans. The characteristics of rats are similar to those of mice.
1) Lipid metabolism
・ | Lipoproteins secreted from the liver (VLDL) contain apoB-100 in humans and rabbits, but apoB-48 in mice and rats. This difference is thought to be due to the following: In mice and rats, the apobec-1 gene is expressed in the liver, leading to the insertion of a stop codon during synthesis of apoB-100 protein, resulting in the production of apoB-48 protei(Hum Gene Ther 1996; 7:943-957). In human and rabbit liver, the apobec-1 gene is not expressed in the liver (Hum Gene Ther 1996; 7:943-957), so VLVL secreted from the liver contains apoB-100, but not apoB-48.
Lipoprotein particles containing apoB-48 bind to remnant receptors in the liver and are rapidly taken up from the circulation, whereas lipoprotein particles containing apoB-100 are taken up by the liver via the LDL receptor pathway rather than the remnant receptor pathway, and take longer to disappear from the circulation. (Li X, et al. J Lipid Res 1996;37:210-220). |
・ | Almost no CETP (cholesteryl ester transfer protein) activity is detected in the plasma of mice or rats (Agellon LB et al J Biol Chem 1991; 266(17): 10796-10801), but CETP activity is present in the plasma of humans and rabbits. CETP is a protein that transfers cholesterol esters from HDL particles to LDL and VLDL particles in plasma. Plasma CETP activity has been shown to be higher in rabbits than in humans and higher in WHHLL rabbits than in normal rabbits (Arteriosclerosis 1986; 6: 345-351). |
・ | In the plasma before heparin administration, high HTGL (hepatic triglyceride lipase) activity was observed in mice, but HTGL activity was extremely low in rabbits and rats, as in humans (Exp Anim 2019;68:267-275). |
・ | Statins have a strong serum cholesterol-lowering effect and are prescribed to more than 40 million people worldwide. Statins are effective in rabbits but do not lower serum cholesterol levels in mice or rats (Atherosclerosis 2013; 213(1):39-47; Biochim Biophys Acta 1986; 877: 50-60; Sharyo S, et al. Kidney Int 2008;75(5): 577-584)。 |
2) Atherosclerosis
・ | Compared to humans and rabbits, mice and rats are less susceptible to atherosclerosis, and atherosclerosis does not occur unless they are fed a diet containing high concentrations of cholesterol and fat.
In humans and rabbits, atherosclerotic lesions develop in various locations in the coronary arteries and aorta, but in studies using mice and rats, lesions are often observed in the aortic sinus (location of the aortic valve), and arterial lesions do not appear to spread throughout the aorta in mice and rats (Pharmacol Ther 2015;146:104-119). |
・ | Various types of arterial lesions are observed in humans and rabbits, including fibrotic lesions and atherosclerosis including vulnerable plaques (Exp Anim 2019;68:293-300). However, in mice, most lesions are rich in macrophages/macrophage-derived foam cells, which appears to be significantly different from human lesions (Pharmacol Ther 2015;146:104-119). |
・ | Macrophages/macrophage-derived foam cells in human and rabbit arterial lesions express VLDL receptors and are thought to be involved in the formation of atherosclerosis, but macrophages in mouse arterial lesions do not express VLDL receptors (Biochem Biophys Res Commun. 2011 Apr 22;407(4):656-662 ). This difference in VLVL receptor expression in atherosclerotic lesions suggests that the mechanism of atherosclerosis development in mice is different from that in humans and rabbits. |
・ | In humans and rabbits, matrix metalloproteinases (MMPs) have been reported to be involved in the destabilization of atherosclerotic lesions, although inconsistent results have been reported in mice (Newby AC. Physiol Rev 2005;85: 1-31). |
・ | The inflammatory marker is C-reactive protein in humans and rabbits, but it is reported as SAP (serum amyloid-p compond) in mice (Torzewski M, et al. Mediators Inflamm. 2014;2014:683598; Pepys MB, et al. Nature 1979; 278(5701):259-261). |
3) Myocardial characteristics
・ | Myosin heavy chain type of cardiac muscle is beta type in human and rabbit, but is alpha type in mouse (Pharmacol Ther 2015;146:104-119). |
・ | The ion channel of myosin is I kr and I ks in humans and rabbits, but I t0 and I slow in mice (Pharmacol Ther 2015;146:104-119). |
・ | The electrocardiogram can be recorded with 12 channels in humans and rabbits, but only single channel in mice. |
・ | In the waveform of the electrocardiogram, T wave is observed in humans and rabbits, but in mice there is no T wave and J wave is observed (Comp Med 2012; 62 (5):409-418). |
X. Studies using WHHL rabbits or WHHLMI rabbits
|